Someone on Bookriot said that when the likes of Stan Lee and Jack Kirby did Thor comics, they not only appropriated Scandinavian culture (Swedish in here) but also injected cultural values that wasn’t there in Norse mythology. While it’s possible for a Jew like Neil Gaiman to do a very faithful adaptation of Norse mythology, the elephant in the room’s that Norse mythology’s not as deeply ingrained among Jews as it does among Swedes, Danes, Icelanders and Norwegians.
This means Marvel’s Thor is actually a rather Jewish Thor, a Thor that’s closer to the Torah than he does to any of the surviving Norse sagas. To put it this way, Marvel’s Inferno is a lad named Dante Pertuz. The association’s there in the sense of being hot as hell as he manipulates fire, nonetheless some Italians (especially those at Guardiani Italiani) have created their own Dante-inspired superhero. He’s called Dante but has nothing to do with fire, his association with the Supreme Poet’s lost on those who aren’t that familiar with Italian culture.
The fact that this character hails all the way from Tuscany (same place where the real Dante is born in) says a lot about how deeply ingrained the Divine Comedy is in Italy that it’s required reading in many Italian schools. Now that’s an authenticity that’s almost impossible for non-Italians to recreate, something Marvel’s Inferno lacks in some regards. If there’s ever a version of Thor that’s closer to Norse mythology, it would be Peter Madsen’s Valhalla.
Denmark isn’t that entirely identical to Sweden, it has a milder climate all over and smaller than Sweden but they’re both descended from the Norse so linguistic and cultural similarities will show up from time to time. This makes Madsen’s Valhalla much closer to actual Scandinavian lore and sensibilities, a closeness Marvel Comics will not and never get. Sort of makes me think if there ever was a superhero comic made by a Greek, it would be Greek in a way Wonder Woman isn’t.
Wonder Woman might be DC’s best known Greek heroine, but she represents a stereotype in the sense of Greeks being stuck in antiquity skipping over the Greece that came under Ottoman occupation and influence (it’s evident in the cuisine). It seems the biggest risks of a character as made by somebody who doesn’t share their ethnicity is that not only do they risk falling into stereotypes, but also share their authors’ cultural values rather than their own.
This isn’t just the problem with Thor but also with Wonder Woman when one considers this, neither of them are written by people sharing the cultures behind their respective mythologies. Well, as far as I know, it’s one thing to throw in nods to mythology but it’s another to be written by somebody of a different culture. To be frank, I don’t know much about Jewish cultures but having some knowledge of the Bible I even think with Thor’s rivalry with Loki seems more like Cain and Abel.
It should be noted that in Norse mythology Loki’s not related to Thor and Odin at all, and Thor’s brother is Balder as far as I know about it. Laufey is Loki’s mother, not his father. I have a cousin who pointed out that there’s this Marvel comics character who became a Valkyrie should’ve rode on Sleipinir (one of Loki’s children alongside Hel and Fenris), an eight-legged horse. Based on what I know about Norse mythology and Scandinavian folklore, Marvel’s grasp on them can be shaky.
Shaky in that Freyja’s the warrior goddess, not Sif and it seemed some of Freyja’s traits were grafted onto her. In Norse mythology, there’s no such thing as an Asgardian only Aesir and Vanir two separate sets of gods. Let’s not forget that Thor had to crossdress to get his hammer back, something his Marvel counterpart never seemed to do. Likewise, Marvel’s Loki never seemed to shapeshift (I could be wrong about this) whereas his myth counterpart did and he became a mare.
Seems like Marvel’s Thor might be the most Judaised and Americanised take to that, perhaps one more radical than God of War’s Thor though I’ve yet to play that game. More radical than Age of Mythology, a game my relatives played and where I thought all Nordic people had red hair. As what somebody else said, Marvel’s Thor seemed to play into non-Scandinavian stereotypes about Scandinavian people.
Not that they can’t be blond at all, but stereotypes reinforce them. Sort of like how portrayals of Italian men as alluring and swarthy reinforces stereotypes, something many real life Italian men will not entirely live up to. Thus, it’s safe to say that Marvel’s Thor is the most Americanised take. He may live up to the blond Scandinavian stereotype, but he’s divorced from his ties to Scandinavian mythology and folklore.
I suspect this is how various ethnic groups feel whenever a facet of their cultures gets stereotyped and appropriated by outsiders, the outsiders have a stereotype of them but the stereotypes aren’t who they really are and how they do things. Marvel’s Thor may seem Scandinavian but also nearly this far apart from his roots in Norse cultures, which just proves this essay’s point.