In the sense that the problem with idolatry’s the tendency to put such characters on a pedestal but knowing the flaws would hurt somebody (that happened to me once or twice). To wit, The Flash’s Caitlin Snow is fallible in the sense that she’s actually a werewolf who’s so spiteful as to use black magic with her dogs to attack animals and people but Barry holds her accountable by making her attack only rats to avoid offending others the next time around.
That would be just as heartbreaking to some people as they don’t expect her to do those things, even if she’s a fallible person if she ever existed in real life all the duping people as a wolf but also made accountable for her actions that’s too close to real life to be escapist. Even if that’s only natural Caitlin would have to face the consequences of her actions, but that would mean she made a big mistake by thinking she’d get away with killing things if she were a wolf.
I think some fans would feel just as bad if let’s say Stephanie Brown smacks Tim Drake around for cheating on her with another girl and watching porn that it’s if she’s not only offended by what he did (though that’s relatable to some) but also where Tim Drake faces the consequences of his mistake where Steph smacks him around for cheating on her. I might as well extend this to IRL characters where they might be neglectful with their children, lose their cool on Instagram a lot and do drugs.
But that would be disappointing to some fans if they knew their favourite celebrity isn’t what they made them out to be, that’s if they not only have mental health problems but do things that shock others like not being careful with the child or caring for animals more than the child. Such people are still sinners or at the very least, fallible like the fictional characters I mentioned before.
Somebody might make a mistake by caring for dogs more than the child, but once neglect comes they only have themselves to blame and by chance, they might learn their lesson on not doing it again the next time. Likewise DC’s Caitlin Snow thinks it’s a good idea to dupe people in the form of a wolf and kill animals with but made accountable by Barry to hunt rats only, as if even for her good spots she is still capable of doing bad.
Or at least fallible, sometimes wrong for doing things and made to mature along the way.